After the Christmas Rush: Keeping New Customers in January

By · Published · Last updated

December and the Boxing Day sales put people in your shop who have never been there before. Most of them will not come back, and usually nobody asked them to. This is a short plan for giving those first-time customers a reason to return in January and February, when trade is slower and a regular is worth the most.

Disclosure: Shakewell Wallet is our product. The plan works with any loyalty card your staff can issue quickly at the counter.

The moment is the counter

A first-time customer is easiest to sign up while they are paying. They already have their phone out. The offer has to be short enough for a queue: "Would you like our card? Your first stamp is on today's purchase."

  • Put the signup QR code on the counter and on the receipt or bag, so customers can also join at home.
  • If your till supports it, let staff issue the card in a few taps (counter signup).
  • Give the first stamp or points on the spot. A card that already has something on it is kept.

Make January the reward

A stamp card that takes ten visits to complete does little for someone who shops with you twice a year. For seasonal shoppers, set a reward that lands on the second or third visit, or add a bonus that is only valid in January. See stamp cards and loyalty cards for the two models.

One message in the quiet weeks

In mid-January, send one message to the cards issued in December: what is new, or what their card is worth now (lock-screen messages). One is enough. A customer who turns notifications off rarely turns them back on.

A simple timeline

WhenDo this
Early DecemberBrief staff on the one-line offer; put the QR code on the counter and bags
Christmas and Boxing DaySign up first-time customers as they pay; first stamp on the spot
First week of JanuaryCheck how many cards were issued and how many have been used twice
Mid-JanuaryOne message to December cardholders with a reason to visit
FebruaryCompare repeat visits from cardholders with last year's January and February

What to measure

Count the cards issued in December, and how many of those were scanned again by the end of February. That second number is the one that matters. How to measure a wallet loyalty card covers the rest.

Common questions

Is it too late to start in December? No. A simple stamp card can be set up in a day. Start with one card and one offer.

Will staff have time to sign people up during the rush? Only if it takes a few seconds. Use a QR code customers scan themselves when the queue is long, and counter signup when it is not.

What if a customer does not want another card? A wallet card needs no app and no plastic, which removes the usual objections. If they still say no, leave it.

How many messages should I send in January? One. Send a second only if you have something new to say.

All guides

Guides + product

Ready to ship your first wallet card?

Set up takes minutes. 60-day free trial. No card needed.