How to Measure a Wallet Loyalty Card: What to Count
By Michael Chora · Published · Last updated
Teams that come to wallet cards from email tend to ask email questions: how many people saw the notification, how many tapped it. A wallet card does much of its work without a tap. The customer glances at the lock screen, or sees the new balance when they open their wallet to pay. Counting taps misses that. This guide lists what is worth counting instead.
Disclosure: Shakewell Wallet is our product. The measures below do not depend on which platform issues your card.
Count what happens at the till
| Measure | What it tells you | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Cards installed | How big the channel is | Your wallet platform |
| Share of members with the card | How well signup and email are getting the card onto phones | Installs against your member list |
| Scans or stamps per card | Whether the card is used, not only kept | Your point of sale or wallet platform |
| Time between visits | Whether cardholders come back sooner | Sales records |
| Offers used before they end | Whether offers on the card are found in time | Sales records |
A scan or a stamp is a fact about a real visit. A notification count is a guess about attention.
Split everything by phone type
Look at iPhone and Android separately. If Android customers add the card less often, the cause is usually something in the signup steps or the design on that phone, and one combined number hides it. The same card looks different in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, and some features exist on one and not the other, so check your card on both. Use your own customers' split: national figures describe other people's customers.
Look at the card after the first day
Most reports stop at installs. Ask instead when each cardholder last saw something change on their card. A card that has not changed since the welcome offer is a barcode and nothing more. A balance that updates after each sale, a reward that becomes ready, or an offer with an end date gives the customer a reason to look (digital loyalty cards). How pass updates work covers what triggers a change on the phone.
Test against email, fairly
Send the same offer to two similar groups. One gets the email. The other gets the email and the offer on their card, with one reminder (lock-screen messages). Compare offers used and repeat visits, not opens. If your email tool receives loyalty events, such as card installs and points earned, you can build the two groups there (Klaviyo).
What you cannot measure
A wallet card does not tell you who walked past your store or who looked at the card without scanning it. Shakewell does not track foot traffic and does not attribute a sale to a reminder. A visit is known when the card is scanned or stamped. Plan your measures around that (online to in-store).
Common questions
Is the notification open rate worth tracking? Not as the main number. Many customers act on a card without tapping a notification, so it understates what the card does.
What is the first number to look at? The share of your members who have the card installed. Everything else depends on it.
How do I know the card is bringing people back? Compare time between visits for cardholders and for similar customers without the card, over the same weeks.
Why split iPhone and Android? Signup and design problems are often specific to one kind of phone, and a combined number hides them.