Why Loyalty Offers Go Unused, and Where to Look First

By · Published · Last updated

When few customers use an offer, the usual conclusion is that the offer was not generous enough. Often the offer was fine and the customer simply did not have it in front of them at the moment they paid. Before making the next discount bigger, it is worth finding out where this one got lost.

Disclosure: Shakewell Wallet is our product. The questions below apply whatever tools you use.

Four places an offer gets lost

StageWhat goes wrongA sign that this is your problem
SeenThe message never registered: it arrived among many othersLow use even among customers who shop the same day
Found againThe customer knows there is an offer but cannot get back to it at the counterStaff hear "I had a code somewhere"
RememberedDays pass between the message and the next shop, and the offer is forgottenUse is high in the first day and close to nothing after
AcceptedThe code will not scan, or staff do not know the promotionCustomers show the offer and it is not applied

One redemption number cannot tell these apart. They need different fixes: a better send time does nothing for a code that will not scan.

The most useful thing to measure

Look at how long passes between sending an offer and each use of it. If nearly all use happens on the first day, the offer works only while the message is still at the top of the inbox. Customers who shop a week later are being asked to remember it and find it again, and most will not.

You can check this with what most shops already have: the send date, and the date of each sale where the offer was applied.

What fixes each stage

  • Seen: fewer, clearer messages, and more than one channel for offers that matter.
  • Found again: keep the offer somewhere the customer already goes when paying. A card in the phone wallet is one such place (sale offers on the card).
  • Remembered: a reminder shortly before the offer ends, and for shops with a physical store, a card that the phone can show nearby (lock-screen messages). Location reminders depend on the customer's phone settings.
  • Accepted: make the offer something the till can apply, brief the staff, and test one sale. If staff identify the customer by scanning their card, the offer does not depend on the customer finding a code (Shopify POS).

A fair test

Take one offer and two similar groups of customers. Send one group the email only. Send the other the same email and also put the offer on their wallet card. Compare how many in each group used the offer, and how many days after the send they used it. The difference between the groups is what the second channel is worth to you. Run it on your own customers: published averages come from other businesses.

A digital loyalty card is not the only fix, and it only helps customers who have installed it. It addresses the two middle stages, which are the ones a better email cannot reach.

Common questions

Is a low redemption rate always a bad offer? No. An offer can be attractive and still be hard to find at the moment of payment. Check when redemptions happen before changing the offer.

What is the quickest check I can run? Compare the send date with the date of each use. If use stops after the first day or two, customers are forgetting or losing the offer.

Does a wallet card fix every stage? No. It helps customers find the offer again and be reminded of it. It does not fix an offer nobody noticed in the first place or a till that cannot apply it.

Do I need new software to measure this? No. The send date and your sales records are enough for a first look.

All guides

Guides + product

Ready to ship your first wallet card?

Set up takes minutes. 14-day free trial. No card needed.